Four Seasons Costa Rica vs Ritz Nekajui: Same Peninsula, Different Mood
Updated October 2026: I've stayed at both Four Seasons Costa Rica and Nekajui, and refreshed this comparison with firsthand insights on rooms for families of four and five, children's programming, pools, private residences and Four Seasons' upcoming Papagayo Suites.
Funicular descending toward Nekajui's beach, photographed during our family stay. Part transportation, part vacation drama. In the best way.
All photographs in this comparison are original images from my family's stays at Four Seasons Costa Rica and Nekajui, a Ritz-Carlton Reserve. I've experienced both resorts firsthand, from the rooms and restaurants to the pools, beaches and children's facilities.
Four Seasons Costa Rica is the confident classic. Nekajui, a Ritz-Carlton Reserve, is the newer, design-forward supermodel with a funicular. Both sit on Peninsula Papagayo, but they offer surprisingly different vacations.
Over the past year, I've stayed at both resorts, visited several of Costa Rica's leading luxury hotels, and planned and booked trips for numerous clients. Between my own family travels and helping clients choose the right properties, I've learned that the details matter far more than the hotel name: room configurations, beach access, service and how a resort actually works for the people traveling.
For families who want an active, easygoing resort experience, I often lean toward Four Seasons. Nekajui is equally compelling for multigenerational travel, particularly when privacy, beautiful residential accommodations and a quieter atmosphere matter. Neither is universally better. The right choice depends on what you want your vacation to feel like.
The Short Version
Both offer wonderful family experiences and access to the larger Peninsula Papagayo playground. Four Seasons has a livelier, more established resort rhythm, while Nekajui offers a quieter, more residential atmosphere. The right choice depends less on who's traveling than on how you want to spend your time together.
Still Deciding Between Four Seasons and Nekajui?
Both are excellent hotels. That's the easy part. Choosing the right room, deciding which upgrades are actually worthwhile and figuring out which resort makes more sense for your particular trip takes a little more thought.
I've stayed at both, have excellent working relationships with their teams, and can book Four Seasons as a Four Seasons Preferred Partner advisor and Nekajui as a Marriott STARS advisor.
Tell me your dates, who's traveling and what you want the vacation to feel like. I can compare the actual room categories, rates and eligible preferred-partner benefits, then tell you which I'd choose and why.
There's no planning or booking fee to work with me.
Overall Feel
Four Seasons feels like a true luxury resort built for families. Warm, polished, full of life. The kind of place where kids feel at home and parents feel taken care of. It has a natural energy to it, the kind that makes you want to wander around in your sandals with a coffee.
Nekajui feels more curated. A little sleeker and more design-forward. Calm without being quiet. The architecture and lighting do half the heavy lifting of relaxing you. It’s not trying to be everything to everyone, which is exactly why it works.
The Adventures: Different Hotels, Same Peninsula Playground
One important thing I would not use to choose between Four Seasons and Nekajui is the off-resort activities. Both properties work with Papagayo Explorers, the peninsula's adventure outfitter, for experiences including ziplining, wildlife excursions, guided hikes, off-roading and more.
So if you've heard that the ziplining at Four Seasons is incredible, it is. But those ziplines aren't exclusive to Four Seasons. Nekajui guests can enjoy the same adventure program at Palmares Preserve, along with the broader Peninsula Papagayo activities. Individual guides and availability may vary, but you're not choosing between two entirely different sets of excursions.
There's also Papagayo Park, the peninsula's new 23-acre recreation hub, which opened in December 2025. Guests of Four Seasons, Nekajui and Andaz can access the park, with tennis, pickleball and padel courts, pools, a pump track, art studio, splash pad and children's adventure areas. Some activities require reservations or additional fees.
This is particularly useful for families planning a longer stay. Whether you're at Four Seasons or Nekajui, the kids can have their fill of ziplining, pool time and activities at Papagayo Park.
The real differences are what happens when you return to your hotel: the rooms, beaches, pools, dining, children's programming and overall atmosphere. I wouldn't choose Four Seasons simply because someone told me the excursions were wonderful. They're wonderful from Nekajui, too.
Rooms and Suites: What Actually Works for Families of Four and Five
One of the biggest differences between Four Seasons Costa Rica and Nekajui comes down to something considerably less glamorous than a funicular: the beds.
At Four Seasons, a family of four can technically share a room with two double beds. But a room that sleeps four and a room where four people sleep comfortably are not necessarily the same thing. Particularly as children get older, two double beds can feel tight. For families who want more space, I often recommend a king room connecting to either another king or a room with two doubles. It's a more expensive arrangement, but having separate sleeping spaces can be worth every penny.
Nekajui solves much of this problem with its spacious two-queen rooms. We stayed in an Ocean Vista room with two queen beds, and I was impressed by both the generous layout and how comfortable it felt as a family. For four people, this is an enormous advantage. You can have proper queen beds without automatically needing a suite or a second room. The large terrace also gives parents somewhere to relax after the children go to sleep.
Four Seasons also has ten new one-bedroom Papagayo Suites available for stays beginning December 17, 2026. With a separate living area, a generous terrace and 1,206 square feet of space, they're worth considering for families of four who want more room without booking two connecting rooms. Their published occupancy is two adults and two children, though, so they aren't a solution for a family of five.
What About Families of Five?
This is where room configuration becomes especially important. Neither Four Seasons' standard two-double room nor Nekajui's two-queen room accommodates five guests under the published occupancy rules.
At Four Seasons, I would usually explore connecting rooms, either king-to-king with a rollaway or a king connecting to a two-double room. For families with very young children, a one-bedroom Canopy Suite may also be worth discussing directly with the hotel, although its published occupancy is four, so any exception would need explicit approval.
At Nekajui, connecting king rooms with an approved rollaway are another possibility. But for many families of five, I particularly like exploring the spacious one-bedroom suites, with a sofa bed and additional rollaway where the children's ages and hotel occupancy rules permit. They offer considerably more living space, and depending on the exact layout, can be a lovely alternative to reserving two rooms.
For larger families and multigenerational groups, both resorts also have excellent multi-bedroom accommodations, including residences and private villas.
This is why I never choose between these two hotels based on the entry-level nightly rate alone. The difference between a comfortable room for four and needing two connecting rooms can change the entire price comparison. At this level, getting the bedroom arrangement right is a much better investment than upgrading simply for a prettier view.
For Larger Families and Groups: Residences and Private Villas
Four Seasons has an extensive collection of private residences, from two- and three-bedroom Canopy Villas and Pacifico Residences to larger estates at Prieta Bay, including the spectacular six-bedroom Casa Las Olas. Many have private pools, full kitchens and generous indoor-outdoor living spaces, with access to the resort's established family amenities. I particularly like these for multigenerational groups who want the privacy of a home without giving up the convenience of Four Seasons.
Nekajui is equally compelling, with contemporary two- through five-bedroom residences and villas designed around private pools, expansive terraces and beautiful shared living spaces. But the real showstopper is Villa Guayacán, an extraordinary ten-bedroom private estate with sweeping Pacific views, an infinity pool, a private chef, concierge and two dedicated Manzus providing around-the-clock service. For a milestone birthday or a trip involving several generations, this is a particularly exciting option. Everyone can have their own space without the family being scattered across half the hotel.
With either property, I would compare the actual bedroom configurations, location within the resort, included services and total cost before deciding. And for larger groups considering properties like Nekajui's ten-bedroom Villa Guayacán, the details matter enormously. I can help compare the residences and private villas at both resorts, review floor plans and confirm exactly what is included before you commit.
Food
I ate very well at both properties, although they approach dining differently. Four Seasons is particularly good at making an excellent meal feel effortless. Nekajui leans more into atmosphere and occasion. And yes, both are accommodating with children, which matters considerably more than anyone likes to admit when dinner involves a seven-year-old.
Four Seasons wins on spontaneity. A very good no-reservation restaurant is a luxury in itself. Sushi, pad thai, coconut curry shrimp, all easy and delicious. You can show up hungry and be fed.
Nekajui wins on atmosphere. Brisa at sunset is almost too pretty. The lighting glows, the colors shift, and the whole thing feels like someone designed the mood board around that exact hour. There’s also a treehouse bar for adults and a splurge-worthy omakase dinner.
Pools: Family Energy vs. Peace and Quiet
My son and I at the Four Seasons Costa Rica pool during our family stay. This easy, lively pool scene is one of the reasons the resort works so well for families.
Four Seasons has great family energy. Plenty of space, attentive service, shade options and that classic resort buzz. But it's not all children and pool toys. Virador Beach Club also has a beautiful adults-only infinity pool overlooking the Pacific, with private cabanas and a quieter atmosphere away from the main resort activity.
ne of Nekajui's beautiful pools, photographed during our stay. Even the pool areas have that serene, design-forward atmosphere that makes this resort feel so different.
Nekajui's pools feel more sculpted into the landscape. The main infinity pool is where everyone gathers, while the adults-only pool offers a quieter retreat. During our stay, it was almost entirely empty, despite there being plenty of adults on the property. I chose not to ask questions. Peaceful would be an understatement.
There's also a pool down at Niri Beach Club, reached by the funicular, which gives families another place to spend the day by the water without relying on the smaller, tide-dependent beach. It's a lovely alternative when you want the beach-club atmosphere with the convenience of a pool.
Both hotels offer excellent options for adults and families. Four Seasons has the livelier family pool scene, while Nekajui offers a little more variety in atmosphere and setting than its serene reputation might suggest. You certainly don't have to choose one resort simply to escape other people's children.
The Adults Only Pool Area at the Nekajui
Beach
Four Seasons gives you two beaches, both easy and family friendly. Classic white sand, swimmable water, and plenty of room.
One of the two beaches at Four Seasons Costa Rica during our family stay. Easy access to the sand is an underrated luxury when traveling with children.
Nekajui’s beach is smaller and more dramatic. A marbled mix of black and white volcanic sand. It disappears at high tide and returns at low tide. Accessed by a very steep, very fun funicular. Snorkeling was wonderful.
Nekajui's volcanic-sand beach during our stay. Smaller, more dramatic and wonderfully atmospheric, although the tides have a considerable say in your plans.
Spa and Wellness
Four Seasons has a very good spa and gym, but Nekajui wins here. The hydrotherapy circuit alone could convince someone to extend their stay. Hot and cold plunges, ocean views, a breezy open-air gym, and a serene yoga studio where even midday classes feel cool.
Nekajui’s hydrotherapy circuit is the kind of spa detail that makes a trip feel like a real reset.
Kid Friendliness
Four Seasons is still the easier family hub, but the distinction is less about access to activities across Peninsula Papagayo and more about what happens inside the resort itself. The updated Kids For All Seasons program gives younger children their own thoughtful space, while Tuanis adds programming specifically for teens. Add the lively family pool scene, two easy beaches, casual dining and a service culture that is exceptionally practiced with families, and the whole stay requires very little effort from the parents.
Nekajui is absolutely family-friendly, and its sophisticated atmosphere shouldn't be mistaken for a lack of children's facilities. Camp Nekajui offers supervised programming for ages four to twelve, while the spacious two-queen rooms, suites with bunk rooms and larger residences make it particularly interesting for families and multigenerational groups. Guests also have access to Papagayo Park and the broader Peninsula Papagayo adventure program. I especially like it for families who appreciate beautiful design and a quieter resort atmosphere without sacrificing things for the children to do.
Countless honeymoons happen at Four Seasons too. It is absolutely not just for families.
Service
Four Seasons has the kind of practiced, polished service that makes a family vacation feel remarkably easy. The little details are handled without much discussion, which is a luxury in itself.
At Nekajui, I found the staff genuinely warm and thoughtful, although there were a few small timing hiccups during our stay. Nothing that spoiled the experience, but noticeable at this price point. Four Seasons felt more established operationally, while Nekajui had a wonderfully personal quality that I appreciated.
Four Seasons Costa Rica or Nekajui: Which Would I Choose?
For families who want an active, easygoing resort with plenty of energy, I'd lean toward Four Seasons. The two beaches, lively pools, casual dining and practiced service make family travel feel remarkably uncomplicated. It's also a wonderful choice for couples who enjoy a little more activity around them.
For a honeymoon, grown-up celebration or travelers who appreciate beautiful design and a quieter atmosphere, I'd lean toward Nekajui. But I wouldn't overlook it for families. The spacious two-queen rooms are particularly appealing for families of four, while the larger suites, residences and villas make it an excellent choice for multigenerational travel.
For families of five, the answer may come down to the available room configurations rather than the resort itself. The cost of connecting rooms versus a spacious suite can completely change which hotel makes more sense.
And I certainly wouldn't choose Four Seasons simply because someone told me the ziplining was incredible. Both resorts use Papagayo Explorers for off-property adventures, so you're largely choosing between the experiences you'll return to, not the excursions themselves.
Both are exceptional resorts. The right choice comes down to how your family travels, how much space you need and whether you prefer a lively resort atmosphere or somewhere a little more serene.
Ready to book your Peninsula Papagayo stay?
Send me your dates, who’s traveling and whether you’re leaning toward Four Seasons, Nekajui or still genuinely torn. I can compare the available rates and room categories, confirm the preferred benefits available for your stay and handle the booking directly with the hotel.
And if Costa Rica will include more than Papagayo, I can also help decide whether to pair the beach with Nayara, AltaGracia or another part of the country.
As a Four Seasons Preferred Partner and Marriott STARS advisor, I work directly with both hotel teams and can confirm the eligible benefits, room options and current offers for your stay.
No fees to work with me ever.
Four Seasons Costa Rica vs. Nekajui: Frequently Asked Questions
Is Four Seasons Costa Rica or Nekajui better?
Neither is universally better. Four Seasons Costa Rica is my first choice for travelers who want a lively, polished resort with easy beach access and a wonderfully established family atmosphere. Nekajui, a Ritz-Carlton Reserve, offers more contemporary design, a quieter setting and exceptional wellness facilities. Having stayed at both, I think the right choice often comes down to the room configuration and how you want to spend your days.
Which is better for a family of four, Four Seasons or Nekajui?
Nekajui has a significant advantage for families of four who want to share one room: spacious accommodations with two queen beds. Four Seasons offers two double beds, which technically accommodate four but can feel cramped, particularly with older children. For more comfort at Four Seasons, I often suggest two connecting rooms. At Nekajui, the two-queen Ocean Vista room can eliminate the need for that extra expense.
Can a family of five stay in one room at Four Seasons Costa Rica or Nekajui?
Neither resort accommodates five guests in its standard two-double or two-queen rooms. At Four Seasons, I generally explore connecting rooms, either king-to-king with approved additional bedding or a king connecting to a two-double room. Nekajui's spacious one-bedroom suites may offer an alternative with additional bedding, depending on the children's ages and approved occupancy. Four Seasons' standard one-bedroom Canopy Suite officially accommodates four, so any exception requires explicit approval. This is a situation where I would confirm the exact configuration before booking.
Is Nekajui kid-friendly, and does it have a kids' club?
Yes. Nekajui has a dedicated children's club, Camp Nekajui, with supervised activities for children ages four to twelve. Four Seasons has Kids For All Seasons and dedicated teen facilities. Both welcome families and offer children's programming. Four Seasons has a livelier family-resort atmosphere, while Nekajui offers a quieter experience without sacrificing thoughtful amenities for children.
Which is better for a multigenerational family vacation?
Both are excellent, for different reasons. Four Seasons is particularly easy for families who want a lively resort with activities for different ages and an extensive collection of private residences. Nekajui is equally compelling for groups prioritizing privacy and contemporary residential accommodations. Its extraordinary ten-bedroom Villa Guayacán, with a private chef and dedicated service, is worth considering for major family celebrations. I would compare actual bedroom arrangements and included services before choosing.
Do Four Seasons and Nekajui share Papagayo Park and excursions?
Yes. Guests at both resorts have access to Papagayo Park, the peninsula's shared recreation center, which also serves Andaz guests. Both Four Seasons and Nekajui work with Papagayo Explorers for ziplining, wildlife excursions, guided hikes and other adventures. Individual activities may require reservations or additional charges. I wouldn't choose one hotel over the other based on these shared experiences. The more meaningful differences are the accommodations, beaches, pools, dining and atmosphere within each resort.
Which has better beaches and swimming pools?
Four Seasons has the easier beach setup, with two accessible beaches and a lively family pool scene. It also has an adults-only infinity pool at Virador Beach Club. Nekajui's beach is smaller and more affected by the tides, with access by funicular. However, Nekajui also has beautiful infinity pools, a quieter adults-only pool and another pool at Niri Beach Club. Both provide plenty of places to relax by the water, even if the ocean has other ideas.
Is Nekajui better for a honeymoon than Four Seasons Costa Rica?
For a honeymoon or romantic celebration, I would often lean toward Nekajui for its dramatic architecture, beautiful sunset settings, spa and quieter atmosphere. But Four Seasons is also wonderful for couples, especially those who enjoy a little more resort energy, excellent dining and easy beach days. I wouldn't rule out either without considering the room category and what kind of experience the couple wants.
Is Nekajui more expensive than Four Seasons Costa Rica?
Not necessarily. Rates vary by season, room category and available offers. For a family of four, Nekajui's two-queen room might be considerably more economical than booking two connecting rooms at Four Seasons. For families of five or larger groups, suites and residence configurations can change the comparison again. I would look at the total cost of accommodations that actually work for your group rather than compare the cheapest available rooms.
Can you stay at Four Seasons and visit Nekajui, or vice versa?
You can generally arrange dining at the other resort, subject to restaurant reservations and current access policies. The properties are a short drive apart, making dinner at the other hotel an appealing option. However, staying at one does not automatically grant access to the other's swimming pools, beach loungers, spa facilities or other guest-only amenities. I would confirm any visit in advance.
Is it worth splitting a stay between Four Seasons and Nekajui?
For most shorter trips, I would choose one resort. They share the same broader Peninsula Papagayo setting and access to many of the same off-property adventures, so changing hotels isn't necessary to experience the destination. On a longer vacation, a split stay can make sense if you particularly want both resort experiences. Otherwise, I would choose the property and room configuration that best fit the trip and settle in.
Read Next
Still planning Costa Rica? These are the pages I’d read next:
Four Seasons Costa Rica Review →
My full firsthand review of the resort, including rooms, dining, beach, pools and what it’s actually like with kids.
Nekajui Ritz-Carlton Reserve Review →
A deeper look at Nekajui, including the spa, design, rooms and who I think will appreciate it most.
Nayara Springs vs. Tented Camp vs. Gardens →
If you’re thinking about pairing Papagayo with Arenal, start here to figure out which Nayara property fits.
The Best Luxury Wellness Resorts in Costa Rica →
For a wider look at Costa Rica’s best luxury resorts, from beach-and-spa stays to full wellness retreats.
